top of page
Search

Are your employee perks worth the money you spend on them?

Are your employee perks worth the money you spend on them?
Are your employee perks worth the money you spend on them

Guidance from an HR consultant in Camden and Westminster on how to measure whether your benefits are delivering real commercial value or quietly draining your budget.


As a business owner, you're probably spending money on employee perks without knowing whether they're making any difference.


Most of the time, perks get introduced because they seem like a good idea. Nobody goes back to check if they actually changed anything.


That means you could be pouring money into benefits that your team barely notices.


Here's how to take a more strategic approach to your people budget and make sure every pound counts.



Start with a baseline before you spend anything


The single biggest mistake I see with employee benefits is introducing them without first understanding where you stand. If you don't know your starting position, you have no way of knowing whether a new perk has shifted anything.


Before committing any budget, survey your people. Get a clear picture of engagement, satisfaction and attendance. Set a specific target for each benefit you plan to introduce. Then revisit those numbers at three months and again at six months.


If the numbers haven't moved after six months, that perk isn't delivering. Stop spending on it and redirect the budget elsewhere.



Four metrics that tell you if your perks are working


You don't need a complicated reporting suite. Four measures will give you a solid view of whether your benefits are earning their keep.


  • Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS) A single question asked quarterly: how likely are your employees to recommend you as an employer, scored from zero to ten? The result falls between minus 100 and plus 100. It takes about two minutes to run and it's the clearest indicator of how engaged your people are.

  • Employee Satisfaction Score (ESAT) Short pulse surveys run every three to six months give you a deeper view of how people feel about their role and the wider workplace. Paired with eNPS, you get a much fuller picture than either measure gives you alone.

  • Absenteeism rate Track this monthly as a percentage of total working days. If your wellbeing-related perks are genuinely helping, you'll see a sustained reduction over time. If the figure stays flat, those perks aren't landing.

  • Retention rate Review this annually, and ideally break it down by team or role. If turnover is concentrated in one area of the business, that tells you exactly where to focus your attention.



Which perks actually deliver results


Not all benefits are equal. Some offer strong returns relative to their cost, while others look impressive on paper but don't shift the metrics that matter. Through providing HR consultancy services in Camden and beyond, I've seen clear patterns in what works for smaller businesses.


  • Flexible and hybrid working consistently drives the biggest improvement in eNPS across sectors. The cost of introducing it is minimal. What it does require is a clear, written policy. Without that, you'll end up with inconsistency between teams, which breeds resentment rather than goodwill.

  • Enhanced leave and mental health days have a direct link to reducing absenteeism. Employees place a high value on these benefits, and the cost to you is relatively low compared to the return.

  • Learning and development has a measurable impact on satisfaction scores. The effect is particularly strong among employees under 35. Beyond retention, development also improves performance, so you're getting more from your people while they're with you.

  • Financial wellbeing support addresses one of the leading causes of both absenteeism and disengagement. Whether you offer salary advance schemes or access to financial coaching, reducing financial stress has become more relevant than ever given the ongoing cost of living pressures.



Watch out for HMRC implications


Before introducing any non-cash benefit, you need to assess it for HMRC liability. Private healthcare and gym memberships, for example, are classified as benefits in kind. They must be valued and reported through P11D. Failing to do this properly creates a compliance risk that can easily be avoided with the right advice upfront.



Common mistakes to avoid with your benefits offering


There are a few patterns I regularly encounter that undermine the value of a benefits programme.


  • Copying what a competitor offers without any measurement framework behind it is one of the most common. A perk that works well in another business may have no relevance to your workforce.

  • Applying the same benefits to everyone regardless of role or demographic is another. A gym membership, for instance, has no value to someone who doesn't use a gym. Understanding what different parts of your team actually want is essential.

  • Poor communication around benefits is surprisingly widespread. If your people don't know a benefit exists, you're spending money for no return. It sounds obvious, but I see it regularly.

  • Finally, any perk that you can't evaluate within six months needs to be questioned. If you haven't defined what success looks like for a particular benefit, you have no basis for deciding whether to continue funding it.



Questions worth asking yourself


Before reviewing or expanding your benefits offering, consider the following:


  • Do you have a current eNPS or ESAT score, or are you introducing perks without any baseline data?

  • Can you identify which specific benefits are contributing to retention in your business?

  • Have you checked that all non-cash perks are being properly reported to HMRC?

  • Are your employees actually aware of every benefit available to them?

  • When did you last review whether a particular perk was delivering against the target you set for it?



How professional support can help


An independent HR consultant can assess your current position, identify gaps, and build a benefits strategy that ties every pound of spend to a measurable outcome. Whether the goal is improving wellbeing, boosting performance or reducing turnover, having a structured approach means fewer assumptions and better results.


As an outsourced HR consultant in London, I work with business owners to ensure their people investment is delivering genuine commercial value.


If you're unsure whether your current benefits are doing what you need them to do, I'd welcome a conversation. Get in touch and we can look at where you stand and what might need to change.


Contact Progressive HR Solutions:




 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page